Showing posts with label Spanish Mortgage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Spanish Mortgage. Show all posts
Thursday, December 13, 2012
SPANISH MORTGAGE CONTRACT
Do you have a minimum interest rate clause in your Spanish mortgage contract? Are you aware that this could be costing you approximately €2000 annually?
Throughout 2012 the Mercantile Court in Málaga has dictated 7 sentences ordering three banks to pay back considerable sums of money which they were illegally charging their clients through what is called “minimum interest rate clause” stipulated in their mortgage contracts.
The truth is that in this mortgage contracts it is established that at no point in time can the variable rate be inferior to a minimum rate fixed by the bank – this tends to be between 3 and 5%, whilst on the other hand the maximum limit is unrealistic – in the majority of cases this is between 7 and 15%.
The detriment to the consumer arrives when the Euribor descends below the minimum rate stipulated in the mortgage contract – particularly at this moment in time seeming as the Euribor has descended below 1% - and the client has to continue paying as if it were at 3 or 5% because of this “minimum interest rate clause” imposed by the bank. However, the maximum rate will never be reached meaning that the consumer will never benefit from it and the only beneficiary will ever only be the bank.
This banking practice trespasses on the very fundamental principles of contractual good faith and provokes a substantial and unjustified imbalance of contractual obligations, generating a loss in the economy of Spanish consumers at the same time. In fact this same minimum interest rate clause has been mainly responsible for the progressive decline of the Euribor; (this being the main variable mortgage reference rate) not having led to a widespread drop in monthly payments.
Source: MARTINEZ ECHEVARRIA I PEREZ I FERRERO ABOGADOS www.martinezechevarria.com
Thursday, October 11, 2012
BANK SCAM – Ground Clause (Clausula Suelo)
How many times I have said to British people signing Escrituras (Deeds) in front of a Notary when they have purchased property in Spain “well my friends at least in Spain you get to see and keep the deeds of your property, whilst in your country the bank keeps it and only shows it to you if you really kick up a fuss.”
One client from up north once said to me “what’s the point in me keeping it if I can’t read the bloody thing.” He also had a point. What I am getting at is that we mere mortals tend to accept blindly that because we have a lawyer, accountant, and bank manager working for us these people will look after our interest.
Very often it does not work like that, not in Europe and especially not in Spain. I have discovered that my own mortgage, which I was led to believe by my friendly bank manager that the repayments could vary according to the Up and Down of the Euribor. So that Up meant I loose and Down I gain is in fact nothing of the sort, in fact Up I lose and Down I lose is the stark reality.
The most frustrating thing is that I can only blame myself. I had the terms and conditions of the mortgage in my hand, all 25 pages of it and 5 minutes to read it before the Notary called us through, so I just skipped to the resume and it looked good or at least it did not mention the Ground Clause (Clausula Suelo) which was instead neatly slotted three quarters down on page 20.
What the clause says is that if the Euribor goes Up your repayment increases accordingly and if it goes Down like it has now – 1% you get no benefit. As simple as that.
Not all banks have resorted to this deceit, only most of them have and in 2012 Malaga courts have dictated seven sentences forcing the banks to return the money obtained through this con. In some cases the amount runs into thousands of Euros.
How do you know if you have been conned by the bank?
Well I read about this scam in the Spanish papers so I went to see David Perez of Martinez Echevarria Lawyers and they are working on my case. They seem to think that I will get some money back. ‘I live in hope.’
Obviously one thing will change, my friendly bank manager will not be friendly anymore.
Friday, March 23, 2012
PROTECTION OF MORTGAGE DEBTORS

We have received this information from MARTINEZ ECHEVARRIA I PEREZ I FERRERO ABOGADOS and thought we would share it with you.
If you would like further clarification of this information please contact david.perez@martinezechevarria.com
Royal Decree Law 6/2012 of 9 March, on urgent measures to protect mortgage holders out of resources.
Object.
- Establish measures to ensure the restructuring of mortgage debt of those with special difficulties in meeting its payment;
- Relax the foreclosure proceedings.
To whom it applies:
- As a general rule, debtors located on the threshold of exclusion loan or credit agreements secured by real estate mortgage
- Will be generally applicable measures contained in Articles 12 (extrajudicial execution procedure) and 13 (preference for access to aid for tenants).
Threshold. Shall be considered located at the threshold of exclusion those debtors of credit or loan secured by mortgage on your primary residence, when they concur in all of the following:
- Must be the only house owned by the debtor
- Loan / credit granted for purchase without collateral or inadequate personal
- All members of the household must have no earned income or economic activities;
- Higher mortgage payment to 60 per 100 in net income of the household;
- Members of the family unit must lack of assets to meet debt and Mode accreditation requirements. It develops in the art. 3
Moderation of default interest. From the time that the debtor prove that is located on the threshold of exclusion, the applicable penalty interest shall not exceed the result of adding a remunerative interest on the loan agreed a 2.5 per cent on capital outstanding loan. This measure applies, though the financial institution has not signed the Code of Good Practice, as Article 4 that includes the regulation is independent of the Code.
Code of Practice.
Features:
- May voluntarily subscribe to credit institutions or any other entity, professionally, carries out the loans or mortgages;
- Published as an annex to RDL;
- Once signed, compliance is mandatory;
- Either party may compel the other to grant deed of novation of the contract, applying the provisions contained in the Code of Good Practice, with the costs borne by the applicant, the innovation will have the effects specified in Article 4.3 of the Law 2/1994, (no change in range of the mortgage, except increased responsibility or term);
- May be invoked before the courts by the affected party;
- Stay in the Code shall be for a minimum of two years, automatically renewable from year to year;
- The acquisition value of the home being financed must be less than the following limits:
- Cities of more than one million people: 200,000€.
- Over 500,000 or in metropolitan areas of over a million: 180,000€
- Over 100,000 people: 150,000€.
- Other: 120,000€.
- Will be applicable only to the member institutions, debtors and contracts referred to this Royal Decree, not walking its length, as a matter of policy or interpretation, to any other area, although, of course, the member institutions may matter purely discretionary implement the provisions of the Code of Practice to debtors or improve various provisions contained therein.
Procedure:
- Financial institutions should communicate their inclusion in the General Secretariat of Treasury and Finance, who shall publish the quarterly list in Electronic Office and the BOE.
- Monitoring will be conducted by a Commission of Control which is a representation of the Spanish Mortgage Association, the Bank of Spain, the National Stock Exchange and the Ministry of Economy who will chair the committee and have a casting vote .
- The Control Commission shall publish a yearly report on their compliance.
- May be introduced to the Bank of Spain claims arising out of any alleged failure by the banks of the Code of Good Practice, which will receive the same treatment as other claims processing and resolution which corresponds to said Bank of Spain.
Misapplication. The debtor would have benefited both the reduced penalty interest as the provisions of the Code of Practice without qualifying for it, or who willfully and deliberately, seek placed or kept on the threshold, will affect at least the following consequences:
- Be liable for damages that may have occurred for an amount not less than the benefit improperly obtained;
- Pay all costs arising from the implementation of these measures of flexibility.
Fiscal
- ITPYAJD. A new article 45.IB number 23) of the revised text:
"23. The writings of formalization of contractual innovations and mortgage lending to occur pursuant to Royal Decree Law 6/2012 of 9 March, on urgent measures to protect mortgage borrowers without resources, shall be exempt from the quota phase- the notarial stamp mode of this tax. "
- Increase in Value of Urban Land. A new paragraph 3 to Article 106 of the Act Regulating Local Tax:
"3. In transfers made by debtors within the scope of Article 2 of Royal Decree Law 6/2012 of 9 March, on urgent measures to protect mortgage holders out of resources, on the occasion of the payment in your housing provided for in paragraph 3 of Annex of that rule will be considered a substitute for the taxpayer taxable entity acquires the property without the substitute may require the taxpayer the amount of tax obligations met. "
- Income tax. It adds an additional provision to Law 35/2006 of 28 November:
"Thirty-Sixth additional provision. Foreclosed housing. Shall be exempt from this tax the capital gains that could be generated in the debtors within the scope of Article 2 of Royal Decree Law 6/2012 of 9 March, on urgent measures to protect mortgage borrowers without resources, occasion of the payment in your home under paragraph 3 of Annex of this standard. "
Tariffs. The notary and registration duties arising from the cancellation of real rights in cases of mortgage foreclosed mortgaged debtor located in the threshold for exclusion of this Royal Decree-law, give a bonus by 50 percent. The debtor shall not bear any additional cost of the financial institution that purchases mortgage free of charge, ownership of the property mortgaged before.
Extrajudicial execution procedure. This reform is of general application and not only to debtors included in the threshold of exclusion, but only affects cases where the procedure taken against a debtor's residence:
1. The realization of the value of the property will take place through a single auction for that type will be that agreed in the memorandum of mortgage. However, if you submit a bid for an amount not less than 70 percent of the amount by which the good would come to auction, means the property awarded to whoever presents the best position.
2. When submitted the highest bid is less than 70 percent of the type referred to the auction, the debtor may file, within ten days, the third to improve posture, offering more than the 70 percent of the appraised value or, even less than this amount is sufficient to achieve complete satisfaction of the right of the performer.
3. After the said period expires without the debtor of good conduct as provided in the preceding paragraph, the creditor may, within a period of five days, the award of the property or properties for an amount not less than 60 percent of the appraised value .
4. If the creditor not to make use of that authority, means the property awarded to who has submitted the highest bid, provided that the amount you have offered over 50 percent of the appraised value or, still less, cover at least the amount claimed for all items.
5. If the act of the auction no bidder has not, the creditor may, within twenty days, request the award in the amount not less than 60 percent of the appraised value.
6. If the creditor fails to make use of the option referred to above, shall be governed by the provisions of Article 236 n. Regulation of Mortgage (if there should remain deserted auctions held and the creditor fails to do the right goods procured executed, the Notary will terminate execution and close and formally registered the minutes, which opened to the courts that apply).
The reform is to adapt this procedure a set of rules (Articles 234 et seq of the Mortgage Regulations, which refers to art. 129 LH) to the reforms of the Civil Procedure Act that affected their Article 670, 671 and later additions Sixth Additional Provision.
Now, the possibility of three auctions now limited to cases where the property is not the debtor's residence.
But even after this reform, it awards for bids to cover the amount claimed, but this was ridiculous (paragraph 4), also by the creditor, if he acted as a bidder.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

